Skip to content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · Riyadh
العربيةNewsletterContact
Saudi Arabia

Legal expert outlines liability for AI-related crimes

Saudi legal researcher Bandar Al-Ruwaili says AI’s lack of legal personality does not exempt parties from criminal liability, which depends on their role.

Ajel News30 min ago · 2 min read
Saudi legal expert discusses AI crime liability

Key Takeaways

AI

Bandar Al-Ruwaili, a legal researcher and fellow of the Saudi Judicial Association, has stated that the absence of legal personality for artificial intelligence does not mean there is no accountability. He explained that criminal liability for AI-related crimes is determined by the role of each party, whether as a system developer, operator, or user.

Al-Ruwaili, who is also a member of the King Faisal Center for Research and Islamic Studies and a researcher in international law, told Ajel in an exclusive interview that harm alone is not enough for conviction. He said it is necessary to prove both the act and criminal intent—the material and moral elements of the crime—or to establish punishable negligence, along with a causal link between the act and the result. He added that a company itself may be held criminally liable if the law provides for such responsibility and the conditions are met, stressing that there is no criminal liability simply for developing, owning, or using an AI system.

To illustrate, he cited the case of an employee who used AI to imitate a company director’s voice and deceive the accountant into transferring funds to his own account. Al-Ruwaili explained that the employee would be liable for fraud if its elements are proven. The software developer, however, would not be held responsible merely for creating the program, unless it is shown that they intentionally participated in the crime or committed another punishable act.

Smart contracts under legal oversight

On the topic of smart contracts, Al-Ruwaili said the justice system protects the rights of parties by subjecting these contracts to the legal rules governing the validity and enforcement of contracts. He noted that affected parties can seek recourse through the courts or agreed arbitration to claim their rights.

He clarified that automatic execution of a contract does not guarantee its legal validity. In cases of error or breach, it is possible to seek a refund or compensation, even if the transaction cannot be technically reversed.

He gave the example of a contractor and supplier who agreed to automatic payment upon delivery of materials, but the system transferred the funds due to a false electronic signal, even though delivery had not occurred. Al-Ruwaili said the contractor has the right to claim his rights before the competent judicial authority, as the automatic transfer alone does not prove delivery or the supplier’s entitlement to payment.

Dr. Bandar Al-Ruwaili holds a professional doctorate in international arbitration and dispute resolution.